Same design basis
All finalists use the same bottle, BPH, scope and destination assumptions.
Supplier comparison
Compare supplier quotations on one bottle, good-output target, equipment boundary and destination. First resolve required scope and technical exceptions; then use the three-supplier scorecard to organize the remaining evidence. A high score cannot make an unpriced essential function disappear.
A lower quote and a stronger scorecard result answer different questions. First decide whether the proposals describe the same deliverable. Request a written revision where these differences change the purchase.
| Mismatch | Question to send to both suppliers | Required comparison record |
|---|---|---|
| One quote states 500ml; the other only states 5000BPH | What bottle, cap, time and good-output counting point support this rate? | Common reference format and a stated test boundary. |
| Only one quote lists a compressor or cooling unit | Which utilities are generated, distributed and connected within your scope? | Equipment and local-work schedule with included/excluded status. |
| Conveyors appear as a lump-sum allowance | Which drawing revision, route and transfers does this allowance cover? | Quantity or route basis, adjustment rule and integration owner. |
| Installation is described as technician support | Who supplies travel, lifting, local labor, connections and trial materials? | Service boundary and outstanding cost register, not an assumed all-inclusive price. |
Keep a separate gate for unresolved launch requirements. The scorecard is a discussion aid, not supplier certification. Record exceptions in the exclusion and deviation register; compare costs only after the equipment boundary is clear.
| Open requirement | Evidence needed | If still unresolved |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle and closure compatibility | Controlled drawings, samples and agreed format trial. | Do not treat a general size-range statement as confirmed suitability. |
| Accepted production output | Reference format, counting point, time and reject basis. | Keep the output qualification open instead of scoring assumed performance. |
| Required excluded function | Supply owner, compatible duty, interfaces and cost status. | Keep the comparable project total incomplete. |
| Combined operation and site work | Interface owner, revised layout, utilities and test responsibility. | Request a scope revision before project approval. |
| Comparison Area | Record for Each Supplier | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Design basis | Reference bottle, cap, target BPH, water, label, pack and shift. | Confirms offers describe the same project. |
| Main equipment | Machine, model, quantity, rated speed and purpose. | Exposes missing or differently sized equipment. |
| Line interfaces | Conveyor length, height, accumulation and control signals. | Shows whether the proposal is integrated. |
| Change parts | Included bottle/cap formats and extra format pricing. | Prevents later compatibility additions. |
| Utilities | Loads, pressures, flows and supplier connection points. | Supports building and operating-cost review. |
| Documents/testing | Drawings, manuals, test materials and acceptance points. | Defines evidence before shipment. |
| Packing/freight | Export packing, trade term, freight inclusion and destination costs. | Separates machine price from logistics. |
| Service/spares | Installation, training, travel terms, warranty boundary and parts. | Makes after-sales scope comparable. |
| Commercial terms | Currency, taxes, payment milestones and validity. | Avoids comparing totals on different bases. |
Use the scorecard only after the reference bottle, line boundary, destination and exclusions have been normalized. Enter 0 when a criterion is still unknown; an incomplete score should remain visibly incomplete instead of being treated as supplier compliance.
Comparison record
Scores support discussion only. Critical deviations and unknown items still require written closure.
Enter evidence-based scores from 0 to 5. Unknown criteria remain incomplete.
All finalists use the same bottle, BPH, scope and destination assumptions.
Local work, utilities, freight, materials and services are explicitly separated.
The proposed line has been checked against available space and material flow.
Inspection, documents, shipment, installation and support have named responsibilities.
A complete-line offer can still leave important interfaces to the buyer. Add a responsibility schedule beside the equipment comparison and name the party that designs, supplies, installs, connects, tests and accepts each interface.
| Interface | Supplier Answer to Record | Buyer Check |
|---|---|---|
| Treated water to filler | Required pressure, flow, quality, connection size and supplier limit. | Treatment capacity, piping route and cleaning responsibility. |
| Bottle supply to monoblock | Approved bottle, transfer method, buffer and control interface. | Purchased-bottle handling or blower capacity and utilities. |
| Filler to labeler/packer | Conveyor length, accumulation, speed and stop-signal philosophy. | Available space, pack material supply and finished-goods route. |
| Machine utilities | Load, pressure, flow, quality and connection point per machine. | Generation, distribution, local standards and connection labor. |
| Installation and testing | Technician tasks, duration basis, tools, documents and acceptance support. | Site readiness, local labor, travel support and trial materials. |
| Supplier Claim | Evidence or Basis to Request | Comparison Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Rated BPH | Reference bottle, fill conditions, line boundary and stated efficiency basis. | Headline speed is compared against a different bottle or only the monoblock. |
| Multiple bottle sizes | Approved drawings, format list, change parts and adjustment method. | Extra formats require unquoted parts or long changeovers. |
| Complete line | Itemized equipment list, process flow, conveyor scope and exclusions. | The offer ends before labeling, packing or utilities. |
| Factory test | Test scope, materials, duration, checks and recorded acceptance conditions. | Buyer expects a full-output test that was never agreed. |
| Installation support | Supplier tasks, buyer tasks, travel terms, prerequisites and completion record. | Local work and technician costs appear after shipment. |
The example weighting favors technical fit and project completeness because a low equipment total can be misleading when bottle compatibility, interfaces, documents or site responsibilities are unresolved. Adjust the procurement decision outside the tool when your project has different priorities.
| Criterion | Example Weight | Evidence to Review Before Scoring |
|---|---|---|
| Technical fit | 35% | Reference bottle and cap, format-specific output, monoblock selection, change parts, filling method and downstream balance. |
| Project completeness | 30% | Equipment list, conveyors, interfaces, utilities, layout, documents, testing and exclusions. |
| Execution support | 20% | Engineering approvals, FAT, packing, shipment, installation, commissioning, training and spare-parts support. |
| Commercial clarity | 15% | Price basis, currency, trade term, payment milestones, validity, warranty boundary and change-control terms. |
Buyer questions
No. Confirm the design basis and normalize equipment, interfaces, exclusions, freight and service before comparing totals.
It captures local building, utilities, installation materials and commissioning needs that may not appear in the supplier equipment price.
Possibly. Compare the reference bottle, valve count, design margin, downstream scope and performance assumptions before deciding.
Do not compare their totals directly. Create a common equipment boundary, add missing conveyors, labeling, packing, utilities, services and local work, then compare equivalent delivered and startup-ready scopes.
It is a schedule naming who designs, supplies, installs, connects, tests and accepts each machine and interface. It exposes gaps that an equipment list alone may not show.
Record the reference bottle and cap, fill conditions, machine or complete-line boundary, downstream equipment and any efficiency or test assumptions used for the speed statement.
Warranty wording is only one factor. Compare the covered components, exclusions, claim process, remote support, parts availability and buyer maintenance duties, not only the headline period.
Yes. A weighted score does not resolve an excluded required function, unproven output or a missing interface. Keep critical open points separate and obtain written closure. Unknown score inputs remain visibly incomplete; they are not evidence of compliance.
No. Record the missing response, responsible person and due date in the clarification register. An unknown price is not an agreed no-charge item. Do not finalize a comparable total until the required scope and cost basis are addressed.
Send the equipment scope you are comparing and the bottle details. We can prepare a configuration-based quotation for Allot Tech scope.